View non-flash version
Legal Beat The Abandoned Shipwreck Act: Useful Tool for Historic Preservation or Paper Tiger? In 1988, Congress enacted the Aban- doned Shipwreck Act (Pub. L. 100-298, 43 U.S.C. §§ 2101-2106), in an effort to give states more authority to protect the historical provenance of abandoned shipwrecks in state waters. It was one of the more controversial laws Congress passed that year because it pitted trea- sure salvors and divers, on the one hand, against states and historic preservation- ists on the other. In the end, the states won passage of the legislation, but some twelve years later, the question remains whether the Act has had the intended effect. Two significant decisions since 1988 have called into question the law's stated Congressional policy. The Abandoned Shipwreck Act and Congressional Policy First, a description of the Act itself. The Abandoned Shipwreck Act (ASA) asserted title of the United States to any "abandoned shipwreck" that is (1) embedded in submerged lands of a State, (2) embedded in coral formations protected by a state, or (3) on submerged lands of a state and included in or deter- mined eligible for inclusion in the National Register, and transferred this title to the states in or on whose sub- merged lands the shipwreck is located. Submerged lands include lands beneath state waters generally out to three nauti- cal miles. The stated policy of Congress in enacting the ASA was to allow states to protect natural resources and habitat areas, guarantee recreational exploration of shipwreck sites, and allow for appro- priate public and private sector recovery of shipwrecks. Congress also declared that the law of salvage and the law of finds - traditional admiralty principles for the recovery of shipwrecks - were not to apply to abandoned shipwrecks to which title had been transferred. Although it was a small law by today's standards, it attempted to modify 200 years of admiralty law applicable to the recovery and ownership of shipwrecks. Perhaps, with hindsight, the goals were too ambitious. Brother Jonathan and the Eleventh Amendment In 1998, the Supreme Court, in a turgid decision construing the applica- tion of the Eleventh Amendment to the ASA, ruled that the Eleventh Amend- ment was not a bar to a federal court's jurisdiction over an admiralty claim brought by a salvor who had located S.S. Brother lonathan in California waters. 38 California v. Deep Sea Research, 523 U.S. 491 (1998). The Eleventh Amend- ment generally protects the States from being sued in federal court without their consent. Although the Court's decision is limited in its effect, and did not reach the question of the underlying constitu- tionality of the ASA, it still may have a chilling impact on state claims to ship- wrecks abandoned in their waters. To review the facts briefly, Deep Sea Research, Inc. (DSR), a salvage compa- ny, claimed to have located the ship known as Brother Jonathan in Califor- nia's territorial waters. The vessel, a 220-ft., (67 m) wooden-hulled, double side-wheeled steamship, sank in 1865 after striking a submerged rock during a voyage between San Francisco and Van- couver. Most of the ship's passengers and crew perished. The ship's cargo included a shipment of up to $2 million in gold. In 1991, DSR filed an action in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California seeking rights to the wreck of Brother Jonathan and its cargo. The State of California intervened, claiming it had title to the wreck under the ASA. According to California, the ASA applied because the vessel was abandoned and was both embedded on state land and eligible for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places. DSR disputed the State's title claim and also argued that the ASA could not divest the federal courts of the exclusive admiralty and maritime jurisdiction con- ferred by Article III, Sec. 2 of the Unit- ed States Constitution. Both the district court and the court of appeals sided with the salvor. The Supreme Court granted certiorari to address the question whether a state's Eleventh Amendment immunity was different in an in rem admiralty action and whether it depends upon evidence of the State's actual pos- session of the res, i.e., the wreck or part thereof, or whether the State can assert bare ownership under cover of the ASA. Although the Supreme Court has been the jealous guardian of the states' pre- rogatives under the Eleventh Amend- ment, especially in recent years, in this case, the Court distinguished the appli- cation of the Eleventh Amendment in more traditional cases from those in which the federal courts are exercising in rem admiralty jurisdiction. The Court was reluctant to disrupt the federal courts' "constitutionally established jurisdiction" in the area of admiralty jurisdiction, and concluded that where a vessel is not in the actual possession of a sovereign, as it was not in the case of Brother Jonathan, the Eleventh Amend- ment does not bar federal jurisdiction over the vessel. The district court could resolve the dispute between DSR and the State of California. 523 U.S. 491 at 507-508. The ASA was intended to grant addi- tional powers to states, and to allow claims to abandoned shipwrecks located in state waters to be adjudicated essen- tially in state courts. In state courts, pre- sumably state historic preservation law would apply to the recovery and protec- tion of wrecks. But, the Supreme Court has put this presumption in serious doubt, allowing federal courts sitting in • SAILOR SALES AND SERVICE AGENTS ANTILLES (NETHERLANDS) Radio-Holland Caribbean N.V. - Curacao NA Phone: +599 94 612577 Fax: +599 94 612723 ARGENTINA SEN S.R.L. Buenos Aires Ptione: +54 114 361 1496 • Fax:+54 114 361 2606 AUSTRALIA Rubin Group Pty Limited • Artarmon NSW Ptione: +61 2 94392333 • Fax: +61 2 94392278 AMI sales • O'Connor, Western Australia Ptione: +61 89 337 3266 Fax: +61 89 314 2929 BAHRAIN Aeradio Technical Services • Mina Salman Port Ptione: +973 727790 Fax: +973 727811 BELGIUM Antwerp Manne Radio Company N.V. • Antwerp Ptione: +32 3 202 0499 Fax: +32 3 202 0493 BRAZIL O.L Naval Ltda. - Rio de Janeiro Ptione: +55 21 509 8667 • Fax: +55 21 242 7934 BULGARIA International Marine Technologies Ltd. • Rousse Phone: +359 82 228216 Fax: +359 82 822230 CANADA Radio Holland (Canada) Ltd. • North Vancouver Phone: +1 604 293 2900 • Fax: +1 604 293 2930 CHILE Serprotec Ltda • Valparaiso (Deep Sea) Phone: +56 32 232780 • Fax: +56 32 212215 Simrad SA Santiago (Fishing) Ptione: +56 2 235 1068 Fax: +56 2 235 8732 COLOMBIA ElectrOnica Mantima Ltda. Cartagena Ptione: +575 663 3789 Fax: +575 663 3643 CROATIA BELAM-Zastupstvo i Servis • Rijeka Phone: +385 51 672343 • Fax: +385 51 672179 CYPRUS A P Hadjipieros Ltd. • Limassol Ptione: +357 5 345972 Fax: +357 5 345973 ECUADOR Industrial Anabra C. Ltda - Guayaquil Phone: +593 4 309766 • Fax: +593 4 313694 Nautical dei Ecuador Manta Ptione: +593 5 628900 Fax: +593 5 628910 EGYPT Suez Electronics Engineering & Trading Ltd. • Cairo Ptione: +20 2 2742911 Fax: +20 2 2745219 ESTONIA VS RSTA Tallinn Phone: +372 6 312082 Fax: +372 6 410114 FAROE ISLANDS S.P. Radio A/S Denmark Ptione: +45 96 34 61 00 • Fax: +45 96 34 61 01 (tor further information) FINLAND ASPO Systems Oy • Espoo Ptione: +358 9 435 5670 Fax: +358 9 435 56710 Navidec Oy • Helsinki Ptione: +358 9 700 17 780 Fax: +358 9 179 830 FRANCE Geolink • Roquevaire Ptione: +33 4 42 32 99 00 Fax: +33 4 42 32 94 95 SDM Electronique • Sartrouville Cedex Ptione: +33 1 39 146833 Fax: +33 1 39 133022 GERMANY Elna GmbH • Rellingen/Hamburg Ptione: +49 4101 30100 • Fax: +49 4101 301214 GIBRALTAR Electro Med Manna Bay Ptione: +350 77077 Fax: +350 72051 GREECE Marac Electronics S.A. • Perama - Piraeus Ptione: +30 1 43 14361 • Fax: +30 1 43 14234 GREENLAND S.P Radio A/S • Denmark Ptione: +45 96 34 61 00 • Fax:+45 96 34 61 01 (tor further information) HOLLAND Radio-HollanO Manne B.V • Rotterdam Ptione: +31 10 4283344 • Fax: +31 10 4281498 Sailtron B.V. • Utrecht Ptione: +31 30 2840850 • Fax: +31 30 2937642 HONG KONG Radio Holland B.V. • Kwai Chung N.T. Phone: +852 24239007 • Fax: +852 24805898 Hoi Tung Communication & Navigation Co. Ltd Phone: +852 25421262 • Fax: +852 25431137 ICELAND Radiomidun Ltd. • Reykjavik Ptione:+354 511 1010 • Fax:+354 511 1020 INDIA Elcome Marine Services Pvt. Ltd. New Bombay Phone: +91 22 762 91 26 Fax: +91 22 762 91 50 INDONESIA PT Panorama Timur Jaya • Jakarta Phone: +62 21 475 6788 • Fax: +62 21 475 1688 IRAN Kaman Hormozgan Manne Engineering • Tehran Phone: +98 21 222 8020 Fax: +98 21 222 4502 ISRAEL Alhout-Yam Ltd • Haifa Phone: +972 4 8605553 • Fax: +972 4 8627404 ITALY Compagnia Generate Telemar • Roma Phone: +39 063 221 800 • Fax: +39 063 240 148 Generalmare est S.R.L • Chiavari Phone: +39 0185 323 356 • Fax: +39 0185 322 731 IVORY COAST Nautical Atrique - Abidjan Phone: +225 250136 • Fax: +225 250137 JAPAN Kaigai Gijyutsu K.K. • Yokohama Ptione: +81 45 6647318 • Fax: +81 45 6647320 KOREA Samyang Radio Co. Ltd. • Pusan Phone: +82 51 413 5000 • Fax: +82 51 413 5002 Turn-On Electronics Company • Pusan Phone: +82 51 462 3930 • Fax: +82 51 462 3089 KUWAIT Elcome International - Safat Phone: +965 2406822 • Fax: +965 2406833 LATVIA / LITHUANIA Firma REIDS • Riga Ptione: +371 7801159 Fax: +371 7801158 LEBANON Selmar Electronics SA.R.L.- Beirut Phone: +961 1 491 489 • Fax: +961 1 495 325 MALTA Medcomms Ltd. • Gzira Phone: +356 335521 Fax: +356 310820 MOROCCO Soremar Casa Casablanca Ptione: +212 2 442802 Fax: +212 2 305385 NAMIBIA Radio Electronic c.c. • Walvis Bay Phone: +264 64 207 483 1 264 64 206 916 NEW ZEALAND Wrights Ltd. • Wellington Phone: +64 4 568 8975 Fax: +64 4 568 8361 NIGERIA Netarcomms Nigeria Ltd. • Lagos State Phone: +234 1 470 2959 • Fax: +234 1 545 2376 NORWAY SAILOR Norge as - Oslo Phone: +47 23 06 9340 Fax: +47 23 06 9341 SULTANATE OF OMAN Elcome International • Muttrat Phone: +968 788 802 • Fax: +968 788 809 PAKISTAN international Aeradio Pakistan (Pvt) Ltd. • Karachi Phone: +92 21 5837800 • Fax: +92 21 5870331 REPUBLIC OF PANAMA Proveedora Tecnica, SA • Panama Phone: +507 227 3533 Fax: +507 227 1053 POLAND EPA Ltd. • Szczecin Phone: +48 914 874 B85 • Fax: +48 914 875 014 PORTUGAL Nautel - Electronica Maritima, Lda. • Lisbon Phone: +351 1 39 20 940 Fax: +351 1 39 20 949 QATAR Eastern Technical Services Co. • Doha Ptione: +974 477412 • Fax: +974 478282 RUMANIA Imsat Maritime SA Constanta • Constanta Ptione: +40 41 639038 • Fax: +40 41 674356 RUSSIA Transas Eurasia Lid. • St. Petersbuig Phone: +7 812 325 3131 • Fax: +7 812 567 1 901 Morelron Ltd • Murmansk Phone: +47 8510144 • Fax: +47 85 1 0144 SAUDI ARABIA Key Communications Development Ltd. • Dammam Ptione: +966 3 8336940 Fax: +966 3 8330728 SINGAPORE Radio Holland Singapore • Singapore Phone: +65 8622218 • Fax: +65 8622430 SOUTH AFRICA Cape Maritime Electronics (Pty.) Ltd. - Cape Town Phone: +27 21 551 3204 • Fax: +27 21 551 3206 Radio Holland Group • Paarden Eiiand (Cape Town) Phone: +27 21 511 0864 Fax: +27 21 511 7577 SPAIN Nautical • San Sebastian de los Reyes (Madrid) Phone: +34 91 6549411 • Fax: +34 91 6549600 SWEDEN Vingtor Marine AB • Askim/Goteborg Phone: +46 31 668400 • Fax: +46 31 683660 Satpool • Goteborg Phone: +46 31 7091550 • Fax: +46 31 7094002 TAIWAN R.O.C. Unimax Electric & Co., Ltd. • Kaohsiung Phone: +886 7 815 9775 • Fax: +886 7 815 1775 THAILAND A. & Manne (THAI) Co., Ltd. • Samutprakarn Phone: +66 2 703 5544 Fax: +66 2 703 55 25 TURKEY Eiektro-Deniz Ltd. • Istanbul Phone: +90 216 392 77 29 • Fax: +90 216 392 8018 UNITED ARAB EMIRATES Elcome international L.L.C. - Dubai Ptione: +971 4 3241333 • Fax: +971 4 3243465 UNITED KINGDOM Ships Electronic Services Ltd. • Rochester (Kent) Phone: +44 1634 295500 • Fax: +44 1634 295536 URUGUAY Electromaritima Uruguaya Ltda. • Montevideo Phone: +598 2 924 77 89 • Fax: +598 2 924 71 38 USA Radio-Holland USA Inc. • Houston (Texas) Ptione: +1 713 943 3325 Fax: +1 713 943 3802 Circle 312 on Reader Service Card
